Mary vs. Martha

August 21st, 2015

Is the conflict between Mary and Martha a clash of incompatible lifestyles, the working life vs. the contemplative life? The Theology of Work project suggests a different way to view this poignant story and explains how we should be like both Mary and Martha. 

In the story of Martha and Mary (Luke 10:38-42), Martha works to prepare dinner while Mary sits and listens to Jesus. Martha asks Jesus to rebuke her sister for not helping, but instead Jesus commends Mary.

Regrettably, this story has often suffered from dubious interpretations, with Martha becoming the poster child for all that is wrong with the life of busyness and distraction, or what the Medieval Church called the active or working life of Martha, which was permitted but inferior to the perfect life of contemplation or the monastery. But the story must be read against the backdrop of Luke’s Gospel as a whole, where the work of hospitality (a vital form of generosity in the ancient Near East) is one of the chief signs of the in-breaking of God’s kingdom.

Mary and Martha are not enemies but sisters. Two sisters squabbling about household duties cannot reasonably be construed as a battle of incompatible modes of life. Martha’s generous service is not minimized by Jesus, but her worries show that her service needs to be grounded in Mary’s kind of love for him. Together, the sisters embody the truth that generosity and love of God are intertwined realities. Martha performs the kind of generosity Jesus commends in Luke 14:12-14, for he is someone who cannot pay her back in kind. By sitting at Jesus’ feet, Mary shows that all our service ought to be grounded in a lively personal relationship with him.  Following Christ means becoming like Martha and Mary. Be generous and love God. These are mutually reinforcing, as is the two sisters’ relationship with each other.

Read the entire commentary on Luke at the The Theology of Work Project.

© 2001 - 2015 Theology of Work Project. All rights reserved. Reprinted with permission from Theology of Work Project.

Channel(s): Doing Your Job